Title 1: Study the historian before their work?
Areas of knowledge: History and one other
The question: Adapting E.H. Carr, the title asks whether studying a historian before studying their work is good advice.
How to argue it: Knowing an author's background helps reveal perspective and bias, but can slide into judging claims by who made them. Ask whether knowledge should be judged on evidence and method alone, or alongside the knower.
Examples to consider: Cold War accounts of the same events by US and Soviet historians; blind peer review in the natural sciences.
Common mistake: Only discussing bias without weighing the limits of studying the person first.
Title 2: Is failure necessary for producing knowledge?
Areas of knowledge: Two areas of knowledge of your choice
The question: To what extent is failure a necessary part of producing knowledge?
How to argue it: Separate necessary from helpful. Falsification in science relies on failure, while a mathematical proof can succeed first time; publication bias also hides failures.
Examples to consider: The Michelson–Morley experiment's null result; Edison's filament trials; drafts and sketches in the arts.
Common mistake: Treating useful failure as necessary failure.
Title 3: Why are ideas more appealing than facts?
Areas of knowledge: The human sciences and one other
The question: Why do ideas tend to appeal more than facts in the production of knowledge?
How to argue it: Ideas offer explanation and meaning; facts do not speak for themselves. But appeal is not truth, so discuss how good ideas are kept in check by facts.
Examples to consider: Economic theories that clash with data; the popularity and later critique of the Stanford prison experiment.
Common mistake: Not defining ideas and facts before comparing them.
Title 4: Should artists and natural scientists care equally about ethics?
Areas of knowledge: The arts and the natural sciences (both fixed)
The question: Should artists and natural scientists be equally concerned with ethical questions?
How to argue it: Compare where the ethical risks come from: research can directly harm people or the environment, while the effects of art are more indirect but real. Ask whether equal concern is measured by consequences, responsibility or freedom.
Examples to consider: The gene-edited babies case; artworks using contested subjects or real people's images.
Common mistake: Discussing one area in depth and the other in passing.
Title 5: Does the need to share knowledge create problems for producing it?
Areas of knowledge: Two areas of knowledge of your choice
The question: Does the need to share knowledge create difficulties for producing it?
How to argue it: Sharing brings peer review and correction, but also simplification, publish-or-perish pressure and tailoring to an audience.
Examples to consider: Preprints during the pandemic; how museum displays select what history to show.
Common mistake: Only praising sharing without addressing the difficulties.
Title 6: Why is intuition valuable without evidence?
Areas of knowledge: Mathematics and one other
The question: If intuition lacks evidence, why is it so valuable in producing knowledge?
How to argue it: Intuition often supplies conjectures and direction, which proof and evidence then test. Include cases where intuition misleads.
Examples to consider: Ramanujan's conjectures; the Monty Hall problem where intuition fails; clinicians' experienced judgement.
Common mistake: Accepting the premise without asking whether intuition really lacks evidence.